CenterTaskbar vs. Built‑In Windows Centering: Which Is Better?Centering the taskbar icons is a common aesthetic tweak many Windows users make to achieve a cleaner, more modern desktop look. With native options in Windows 11 and third‑party tools like CenterTaskbar, you can place icons in the middle of the taskbar rather than aligned to the left. This article compares CenterTaskbar (a dedicated utility) and Windows’ built‑in centering to help you choose the solution that best fits your needs.
Quick verdict
- Best for simplicity and security: Built‑in Windows centering.
- Best for customization and compatibility with older Windows: CenterTaskbar.
What each option does
-
Built‑in Windows centering
- Windows 11 introduced native centering of Start button and app icons. The feature is accessible through Settings → Personalization → Taskbar where you can choose to center icons or keep them left aligned (or use the taskbar alignment control available in taskbar context menus).
- Centering is implemented at the OS level, which means it’s maintained across updates and generally integrates smoothly with system features like taskbar previews, jump lists, and notifications.
-
CenterTaskbar (third‑party utility)
- CenterTaskbar is a lightweight tool that repositions taskbar icons to the center on Windows versions that do not natively support it (notably Windows 10) or offers alternate centering behaviors on versions that do.
- It often works by adjusting how the taskbar arranges icon groups or by placing a spacer element so icons appear centered. Some versions allow additional tweaks or toggle behaviors not available in native Windows settings.
Compatibility and OS support
-
Built‑in Windows centering
- Windows 11: Fully supported, stable, and continuously updated.
- Windows 10 and earlier: Not available natively (requires third‑party tools).
-
CenterTaskbar
- Windows 10: Useful and commonly used to mimic Windows 11 behavior.
- Windows 11: Can still be used for alternate effects or to recover specific legacy behaviors; however, it may conflict with future system updates or duplicate native features.
- Older builds/preview releases: Third‑party tools sometimes break after major Windows updates until updated by their authors.
Ease of use and setup
-
Built‑in Windows centering
- Setup: Two to three clicks in Settings. No downloads, no installers.
- Maintenance: Zero — Microsoft handles updates.
- Reversibility: Native toggle makes it trivial to revert.
-
CenterTaskbar
- Setup: Requires finding, downloading, and running the utility (may be portable or installer-based).
- Maintenance: Depends on the developer; you may need to update after OS patches.
- Reversibility: Usually easy (close/uninstall the app), but behavior may vary by implementation.
Customization & features
-
Built‑in Windows centering
- Offers a simple on/off alignment. Minimal customization beyond that.
- Integrates with taskbar behaviors like grouping, notifications, and system tray handling as designed by Microsoft.
-
CenterTaskbar
- Often provides additional options: exact spacing, centering only certain icons, or combining with other aesthetic tweaks.
- Some variants allow hotkeys to toggle centering or support different monitor configurations.
- More flexible for users who want precise control over appearance.
Stability & security
-
Built‑in Windows centering
- Stability: High. Tested across releases.
- Security: High. No external code required. Less risk of malware or conflicts.
-
CenterTaskbar
- Stability: Can be excellent but depends on the tool’s quality and timely updates. Third‑party code may break with system updates.
- Security: Varies. Reputable projects are safe, but downloading executables from unknown sites carries risk. Prefer open‑source projects from trusted repositories and verify checksums/signatures when available.
Performance and resource usage
-
Built‑in Windows centering
- Negligible overhead — handled by the system.
-
CenterTaskbar
- Typically lightweight (small memory/CPU footprint). However, poorly written tools may introduce leaks or increased CPU usage, especially after system updates.
Multi‑monitor & docking behavior
-
Built‑in Windows centering
- Handles multiple displays and taskbar settings consistently via system settings (can show taskbar on all displays, etc.). Behavior is predictable and consistent with other Windows features.
-
CenterTaskbar
- Multi‑monitor support varies by tool. Some support per‑monitor centering; others only affect the primary taskbar. If you rely on particular docking behaviors, test before committing.
Use cases and recommendations
-
Use built‑in Windows centering if:
- You run Windows 11 and want a simple, reliable solution.
- You prioritize system stability and minimal maintenance.
- You don’t need fine‑grained control over icon spacing or behavior.
-
Use CenterTaskbar (or another third‑party tool) if:
- You use Windows 10 or an older build and want centered icons.
- You want extra customization not available natively (exact spacing, selective centering).
- You’re comfortable updating the tool after major OS changes and downloading software from trusted sources.
Example scenarios
- Scenario A: Casual user on Windows 11 — choose built‑in centering for simplicity and security.
- Scenario B: Power user on Windows 10 — choose CenterTaskbar if you need left-to-center cosmetic parity with Windows 11.
- Scenario C: Multi‑monitor setup with custom spacing needs — evaluate specific CenterTaskbar forks or alternatives and test carefully.
Alternatives to consider
- TaskbarX — another popular third‑party tool offering animated centering, custom spacing, and advanced features.
- ExplorerPatcher — restores classic taskbar behaviors and can work with other utilities to achieve centering on older systems.
- Manual alignment via toolbars (older trick) — create empty toolbars/spacers to fake centering on legacy systems (clunky).
Final comparison (summary table)
| Criterion | Built‑in Windows Centering | CenterTaskbar (third‑party) |
|---|---|---|
| Ease of use | Very easy | Easy — requires download |
| Stability | High | Medium — depends on tool and updates |
| Security | High | Variable — depends on source |
| Customization | Low | High |
| OS support | Windows 11 (native) | Windows 10 & older, Windows 11 (custom) |
| Multi‑monitor support | Consistent | Varies by tool |
| Maintenance | Minimal | Requires occasional updates |
Practical checklist before using a third‑party tool
- Download from a reputable source (official site or trusted repo).
- Verify digital signatures or checksums if available.
- Read user reports about compatibility with your exact Windows build.
- Keep a restore point or backup in case the taskbar behavior becomes unstable.
- Prefer portable versions that don’t require deep system changes.
Conclusion
If you run Windows 11 and want a minimal, secure way to center your taskbar, built‑in Windows centering is the better choice for most users. If you need advanced customization, are on Windows 10, or want behaviors the OS doesn’t provide, CenterTaskbar (or similar third‑party utilities) gives more control — but requires more care regarding updates and security.
Leave a Reply